4 stars (5)
- Beachview Cottages Sanibel
- Casa Ybel Resort Sanibel
- Sea Shells Of Sanibel Hotel
- Sundial Beach Resort & Spa Sanibel
- Sunset Beach Inn Sanibel
3 stars (16)
- Caribe Beach Resort Sanibel Island
- Island Inn Sanibel
- Kona Kai Hotel Sanibel
- Lighthouse Resort And Club Sanibel Island
- Ocean'S Reach Aparthotel Sanibel
- Pelicans Roost Gulf Front Sanibel
- Sanibel Arms West Hotel
- Sanibel Inn
- Sanibel Island Beach Resort
- Sanibel Moorings Hotel
- Seahorse Cottages - Adults Only Sanibel
- Seaside Inn Sanibel
- Song Of The Sea Hotel Sanibel
- Tarpon Tale Inn Sanibel
- Tropical Winds Beachfront Motel And Cottages Sanibel
- West Wind Inn Sanibel
2 stars (7)
- Anchor Inn And Cottages Sanibel
- Colony Inn Sanibel
- Gulf Breeze Cottages Sanibel
- Parrot Nest Hotel Sanibel
- Shalimar Cottages And Motel Sanibel
- Sunshine Island Inn Sanibel
- Waterside Inn On The Beach Sanibel